Hotels
Hotels in Sugarcreek, OH
This is a 3-star market: 6 of the 9 properties nearby sit in that band, and 1 of them are within a mile of Ohio Star Theater. The hotel search for Sugarcreek starts at Ohio Star Theater, so every distance below is measured from there, nearest first.
Hotels in Sugarcreek: our accommodation partner lists 9 properties within about five miles of Ohio Star Theater, 1 of them within a mile. They average 9.5/10 in guest scores. The 9 nearest are compared below, closest first.
What the hotels in Sugarcreek are like
Before the list, the shape of it. These figures cover every property the search found within about five miles of Ohio Star Theater, not just the 9 shown below, which are simply the closest.
| Measure | Sugarcreek | What it tells you |
|---|---|---|
| Properties found | 9 | Everything listed within about five miles of Ohio Star Theater. The 9 nearest are shown below. |
| Star mix | 1 × 4★, 6 × 3★, 1 × 2★ | 3-star is the largest band here. |
| Average guest score | 9.5/10 | Across the 5 rated properties. Supplied by our accommodation partner, not a StubOrder rating. |
| Within a mile of Ohio Star Theater | 1 of 9 | The rest are a drive or a transit ride. |
| Closest property | Under 0.3 mi | From Ohio Star Theater, in a straight line. |
Hotels in Sugarcreek, closest to Ohio Star Theater first
Pick your dates to price these for the nights you actually want. Nothing is quoted until you do, because a nightly rate for the wrong dates is worse than no rate at all.
-
Carlisle Inn
1357 Old Route 39, Sugarcreek
Indulge in Comfort and Amish Charm Swim Under the Stars: Take a dip in the indoor swimming pool with a retractable roof. Culinary Delights: Enjoy complimentary daily breakfast and…
-
Downtown Escape Great for large families & groups
332 North Broadway Street, Sugarcreek
Luxurious Downtown Retreat in Sugarcreek Modern Amenities and Comfortable Stay Recently renovated, this 5-bedroom holiday home offers 2 living rooms, a fully equipped kitchen, and…
-
Rural & Private Dover Retreat: Close to Wineries!
Escape to charming tranquility at our inviting cottage, nestled just moments from renowned wineries in Dover. Prime Location Experience the best of local wineries with Swiss Herit…
-
Sugarcreek Village Inn
206 SE Factory St., Sugarcreek
Designated Smoking Areas Enjoy the convenience of designated smoking areas at our property. Free Self Parking Take advantage of our complimentary onsite self parking. Complimentar…
-
Morning Mist
9659 Crooked Run Rd SW,, Sugarcreek
Charming Holiday Home Discover our cozy 2-bedroom holiday home with a fully equipped kitchen and outdoor dining area. Towels and bed linen provided for your convenience. Convenien…
-
A Winfield Bungalow
5261 Schneiders Crossing Road Northwest, Dover
Luxurious Accommodation Experience comfort and style in our recently renovated 4-bedroom bungalow with modern amenities like a fully equipped kitchen and flat-screen TV. Convenien…
-
Spacious Ohio Family Home on 5-acre Property!
796 May Valley Rd SW, New Philadelphia
Convenient Amenities: Complimentary Wi-Fi, BBQ grills Self-Parking: Free self parking available Cozy Accommodation: Air-conditioned cottage with fireplace, private patio, and full…
-
Ohio Amish Country Getaway: Fish, Hike, Boat!
Experience the charm and comfort of our delightful cottage in Sugarcreek, ideally located near the iconic Age of Steam Roundhouse Museum and the World's Largest Cuckoo Clock. Comf…
-
Peaceful Cabin w/ Hot Tub in Dundee: Dogs Welcome
Welcome to our charming cottage in the heart of Dundee, where comfort meets convenience! Unwind in Comfort Relax in our air-conditioned cottage, featuring a cozy fireplace and pri…
Want a wider list than the one above? You can also search Expedia's own hotel inventory. We do not show its prices here.
How we earn: StubOrder may earn a commission when you book through the Expedia links on this page. It costs you nothing extra, and it never changes which events, venues or places we show you.
Compare more hotels on Expedia (opens Expedia in a new tab)Staying near a specific Sugarcreek venue
In Sugarcreek the hotels above are already measured from Ohio Star Theater, so its own hotels page below lists much the same properties, with what is on there.
Venues in Sugarcreek
The buildings people book these rooms for. Each links to its schedule and tickets.
What is on in Sugarcreek
The reason most people book a room here. Every date links to live tickets and a seat map.
- From about $62.00View Tickets
- From about $981.00View Tickets
- From about $57.00View Tickets
Opening Night
A Christmas Carol
From about $78.00View TicketsMatinee
A Christmas Carol
From about $78.00View Tickets- From about $78.00View Tickets
- From about $78.00View Tickets
How to read these listings
Every card carries the same facts in the same order, so two properties can be compared at a glance rather than read as marketing copy.
- Distance is straight-line, not walking. We know where the property is and where Ohio Star Theater is; we do not know the streets in between. That is why each card also says walkable, long walk or drive, and why those labels are deliberately conservative.
- Guest scores are our accommodation partner’s, not ours. StubOrder does not review hotels. Where a score appears it is theirs, with the review count beside it so you can judge how much weight it carries.
- The rate is the lowest available for the stay you asked for, for two adults, and it moves constantly. Treat it as a comparison between properties rather than a quote.
- Nothing here is paid placement. The order is distance from Ohio Star Theater, full stop. No property pays to appear or to rank.
Plan the rest of the trip
Email me when a new date is announced, so I can book a room early
Frequently asked questions
How close are these hotels to the Sugarcreek venues?
The hotel search for Sugarcreek starts at Ohio Star Theater, so every distance on this page is measured from there, in a straight line, and each card says plainly whether that is a walk or a drive.
Why are no prices shown until I pick dates?
Because a nightly rate only means anything for a specific stay, and asking for one costs a live request. Pick your dates and every property above is priced for exactly those nights, for two adults.
What kind of hotels are there in Sugarcreek?
This is a 3-star market: 6 of the 9 properties nearby sit in that band, and 1 of them are within a mile of Ohio Star Theater. They average 9.5/10 in guest scores from our accommodation partner.
Does StubOrder sell hotels and tickets together?
No. Tickets come from our resale marketplace and rooms from our accommodation partner, as two separate bookings with separate confirmations.
