Hotels
Hotels in Sag Harbor
The stock is mixed, with 3-star the largest single band at 17 of 59, and 6 of them are within a mile of the centre. Below are the closest properties to the middle of Sag Harbor, nearest first, plus what is near each venue in the city — because if you are here for one event, distance from that building matters more than distance from downtown.
Hotels in Sag Harbor: our accommodation partner lists 59 properties within about five miles of the centre, 6 of them within a mile. They average 6.7/10 in guest scores. The 36 nearest are compared below, closest first.
What the hotels in Sag Harbor are like
Before the list, the shape of it. These figures cover every property the search found within about five miles of the middle of Sag Harbor — not just the 36 shown below, which are simply the closest.
| Measure | Sag Harbor | What it tells you |
|---|---|---|
| Properties found | 59 | Everything listed within about five miles of the centre. The 36 nearest are shown below. |
| Star mix | 4 × 5★, 12 × 4★, 17 × 3★, 13 × 2★ | 3-star is the largest band here. |
| Average guest score | 6.7/10 | Across the 31 rated properties. Supplied by our accommodation partner, not a StubOrder rating. |
| Within a mile of the centre | 6 of 59 | The rest are a drive or a transit ride. |
| Closest property | Under 0.3 mi | From the city’s centre point, in a straight line. |
Hotels in Sag Harbor, closest to the centre first
Pick your dates to price these for the nights you actually want. Nothing is quoted until you do, because a nightly rate for the wrong dates is worse than no rate at all.
-
Breakwater by Rove Travel - 3BR Secluded Retreat
71 Franklin Ave, Sag Harbor
Luxurious Accommodation with Private Pool Indulge in a luxurious stay at Breakwater by RoveTravel, featuring air-conditioned 3-bedroom accommodation with a private pool, ideal for…
-
Faraway Sag Harbor
31 West Water Street, Sag Harbor
Luxurious Accommodations Baron's Cove in Sag Harbor offers elegantly furnished guest rooms equipped with modern amenities, including flat-screen TVs and luxurious bathrobes. Selec…
-
Sag Harbor Inn
West Water Street,45, Sag Harbor
Luxurious Accommodations Experience comfort and style in our rooms with modern amenities such as flat-screen TVs, air conditioning, and private bathrooms. Some rooms even feature …
-
Robeson Retreat
24 Robeson Blvd, Sag Harbor
Convenient Location Explore popular attractions such as Havens Beach and The Hamptons Beaches within walking distance. Visit historical sites like Sag Harbor Old Burying Ground an…
-
Sunset Villa by Rove Beachfront w Deck Pool
Discover the perfect beachfront getaway at Sunset Villa by Rove, where relaxation meets luxury in Sag Harbor. Serene Beach Access Just a leisurely 4-minute stroll from The Hampton…
-
Villa KeyLime
3, Wilson Place, Sag Harbor
Luxurious Accommodation Experience a premium stay at Villa KeyLime with 5 bedrooms, 4 bathrooms, and a private pool. Enjoy the lush garden view from your patio and relax in style …
-
Villa Kimaal - Luxury with pool
33 Carroll Street, Sag Harbor
Luxurious Villa with Private Pool Exquisite Accommodations: Villa Kimaal offers a spacious 5-bedroom villa with top-notch amenities including a flat-screen TV, fully equipped kitc…
-
Villa Guldan - Luxury with pool
Six Pole Highway, Wainscott
Luxurious Villa with Private Pool and Stunning Views Exquisite Accommodations: Villa Guldan boasts a spacious layout with 7 bedrooms, a flat-screen TV, fully equipped kitchen, and…
-
Awarded Lux Sanctuary Pike Pond by Rovetravel
1596 Bridgehampton-Sag Harbor Turnpike, Sag Harbor
Enjoy a Relaxing Stay Surrounded by Nature Step into your vacation home and relish the serene garden views. Take advantage of complimentary Wi-Fi and make memories with a barbecue…
-
Cowgirl Palace
116 Merchants Path, Sag Harbor
Luxurious Retreat in Sag Harbor Experience a stay like no other at Cowgirl Palace, a hidden gem in Sag Harbor offering a private pool, free WiFi, and complimentary parking. Charmi…
-
Beachwood Cove by Rove Travel - 3BR with Heated Pool
Edwards Hole Road 65, East Hampton
Luxurious Amenities Beachwood Cove by RoveTravel offers a range of luxurious amenities including a heated pool, hot tub, and beautiful garden, providing guests with a relaxing and…
-
Villa Edwards Hole
18 Edwards Hole Rd, East Hampton
Luxurious Villa with Convenient Amenities This villa offers designated smoking areas and complimentary wireless internet to keep you connected. Make yourself comfortable in this v…
-
Casa Newmark Holiday home 7 BestStayz.1
112 Northwest Path, Sagaponack
Luxury Vacation Home with Recreational Amenities Indulge in the sauna and fitness center for relaxation. The air-conditioned property boasts a cozy fireplace and a private balcony…
-
SH001 5 Bedroom Holiday home By Senstay
9 Lillian Ln, Sagaponack
Convenient Kitchen Amenities Relax and enjoy the convenience of a fully equipped kitchen with a refrigerator and a microwave for your culinary needs. Entertainment Options Unwind …
-
Villa Charlotte
39 Old Sag Harbor Road, Bridgehampton
Relax by the Pool or in the Garden Unwind in our air-conditioned villas with complimentary Wi-Fi, satellite TV, and daily housekeeping. Convenient Amenities at Your Fingertips Enj…
-
Bluffside Cove by Rove Beachfront w Pool Sauna
Discover a serene getaway at Bluffside Cove by Rove Beachfront w Pool Sauna, where luxury meets comfort in the beautiful Sag Harbor. Breathtaking Views Immerse yourself in stunnin…
-
Luxury Villa 7br 7baths With a Private Pool Hamptons
Bridge Hill Lane 22, Bridgehampton
Enjoy the Outdoors Revel in the scenic views from the garden and make use of barbecue grills for a delightful outdoor experience. Modern Amenities Stay connected with complimentar…
-
Bridgehampton Beauty
52 Woodruff Lane, Bridgehampton
Convenient Location Stay within close proximity to popular attractions such as South Fork Natural History Museum and Nature Center, Channing Daughters Winery, and more. Comfortabl…
-
Private Home near Ocean Beaches, Nature Preserve
32 Whooping Hollow Road, East Hampton
Spacious and Modern Accommodation: Enjoy a comfortable stay in our air-conditioned holiday home with a terrace and free WiFi access. Outdoor Fireplace and Relaxation: Experience c…
-
Villa Red Hut
832 Millstone Road, Water Mill
Outdoor Pool and Terrace Enjoy the outdoor pool and terrace with garden views at this villa in Water Mill. Concierge Services and Gift Shops Take advantage of concierge services a…
-
Luxurious 8 Bedroom Retreat With Pool East Hampton
Bull Run 26, East Hampton
Beautiful Garden Views Complimentary Wireless Internet Access On-Site Barbecue Grills Immerse yourself in the beauty of East Hampton at Luxurious 8 Bedroom Retreat With Pool East …
-
Traditional East Hampton Estate
2 Jasons Lane, East Hampton
Convenient Location Stay at this vacation home in East Hampton for easy access to popular landmarks like The Hamptons Beaches and LongHouse Reserve. Explore the area with the prov…
-
Meadowood Manor by Rovetravel Heated Pool
1653 Millstone Rd Sag Harbor NY 11963, Sag Harbor
Scenic Garden Views: Enjoy breathtaking views from the garden surrounding the property. Complimentary Amenities: Take advantage of complimentary wireless internet access during yo…
-
Villa Lavender
1854 Noyac Path, Sag Harbor
Outdoor Pool and Fitness Center Enjoy the outdoor pool and fitness center during your stay at this villa in Sag Harbor. Convenient Amenities Make yourself at home in the air-condi…
-
Brightwater by Rove Sauna Pool Outdoor Spaces
Escape to Brightwater by Rove Sauna Pool Outdoor Spaces in the heart of East Hampton, where tranquility meets convenience. Unwind in Comfort Experience a home away from home in on…
-
The Sagaponack
3720 Montauk Hwy, Sagaponack
Luxurious Rooms and Amenities Experience comfort and style at The Wainscott Inn with our air-conditioned rooms equipped with free WiFi and private bathrooms. Relax by our seasonal…
-
Villa Direen Modern East Hampton Villa
Outdoor Pool and Garden View Picnic Area and Charcoal Grills Private Plunge Pool with Free Wi-Fi To book your stay at this charming villa in East Hampton, just a short drive away …
-
380 Inn
380 Montauk highway, Wainscott
Enjoy Stunning Views from the Garden Step into relaxation at 380 Inn where you'll find a serene garden offering breathtaking views. Unwind in one of the 20 air-conditioned rooms w…
-
Wainscott Woods Retreat
Discover Wainscott Woods Retreat, where comfort meets convenience in the heart of the Hamptons. Recreation and Relaxation Enjoy a refreshing dip in our seasonal outdoor pool, or s…
-
A Room At The Beach
2668 Montauk Hwy, Bridgehampton
Outdoor Pool and Terrace Enjoy the outdoor pool and terrace at A Room At The Beach, perfect for soaking up the sun or relaxing with a refreshing drink. Complimentary Services and …
-
Topping Rose House
One Bridgehampton - Sag Harbor Turnpike, Bridgehampton
Farm-to-Table Dining Experience Indulge in exquisite dishes made from locally sourced ingredients at our on-site restaurant, sourced directly from our own farm. Luxurious Amenitie…
-
Villa Machis
2765 Deerfield Rd, Sag Harbor
Luxurious Amenities Indulge in the private pool, fully-equipped kitchen, and complimentary wireless internet access. Convenience at Its Best Enjoy access to a fitness center, conc…
-
Bridgehampton Inn
2266 Main St, Bridgehampton
Scenic Views and Modern Amenities: Enjoy stunning views from the terrace and garden while staying connected with complimentary wireless internet. Delicious Dining Options: Indulge…
-
Sandpoint by Rove Travel Modern 5BR w Pool
13 Brander Pkwy Shelter Island NY 11964, Shelter Island
Stunning Garden Views - Immerse yourself in the beauty of the garden right from your accommodation. Complimentary Amenities - Enjoy free wireless internet access and convenient se…
-
Blank Lane by Rove Travel 5BR w Pool Hot Tub
248 Blank Ln Water Mill NY 11976 USA, Water Mill
Beautiful Garden Views Complimentary Amenities Enjoy free self parking and wireless internet access, along with access to BBQ grills. Convenient Location Just a short drive away f…
-
The Pridwin Hotel
81 Shore Road, Shelter Island
Welcome to The Pridwin, a picturesque waterfront resort on Shelter Island! Nestled in a serene natural setting, The Pridwin offers 33 luxurious guest rooms and 16 private cottages…
Staying near a specific Sag Harbor venue
This is usually the better question. The hotels above are measured from the middle of Sag Harbor, which is only the right anchor if the city itself is the trip. If you are coming for one event, what matters is how far you are from that building at 11pm — and in most cities the centre and the venue are not the same place.
Each page below runs its own search from that venue’s own coordinates and sorts by real straight-line distance from the doors, with a plain note on every card saying whether that is a walk, a long walk or a drive.
Venues in Sag Harbor
The buildings people book these rooms for. Each links to its schedule and tickets.
How to read these listings
Every card carries the same facts in the same order, so two properties can be compared at a glance rather than read as marketing copy.
- Distance is straight-line, not walking. We know where the property is and where the centre is; we do not know the streets in between. That is why each card also says walkable, long walk or drive, and why those labels are deliberately conservative.
- Guest scores are our accommodation partner’s, not ours. StubOrder does not review hotels. Where a score appears it is theirs, with the review count beside it so you can judge how much weight it carries.
- The rate is the lowest available for the stay you asked for, for two adults, and it moves constantly. Treat it as a comparison between properties rather than a quote.
- Nothing here is paid placement. The order is distance from the centre, full stop. No property pays to appear or to rank.
Plan the rest of the trip
Email me when a new date is announced, so I can book a room early
Frequently asked questions
Does StubOrder sell hotels and tickets together?
No. Tickets come from our resale marketplace and rooms from our accommodation partner, as two separate bookings with separate confirmations.
What kind of hotels are there in Sag Harbor?
The stock is mixed, with 3-star the largest single band at 17 of 59, and 6 of them are within a mile of the centre. They average 6.7/10 in guest scores from our accommodation partner.
Why are no prices shown until I pick dates?
Because a nightly rate only means anything for a specific stay, and asking for one costs a live request. Pick your dates and every property above is priced for exactly those nights, for two adults.
How close are these hotels to the Sag Harbor venues?
The hotels on this page are measured from the middle of Sag Harbor. For distance from a specific building, use that venue's own page - each one is linked above and sorts every nearby property by real distance from the doors.
Is it cheaper to stay near the venue or in the centre?
It depends on the city and the night. Near a stadium on an event night is usually the expensive option; the centre is usually better value but adds a journey. Both pages exist so you can compare them rather than guess.
