Hotels in New Buffalo
The stock is mixed, with 4-star the largest single band at 26 of 63, and 4 of them are within a mile of the centre. Below are the closest properties to the middle of New Buffalo, nearest first, plus what is near each venue in the city — because if you are here for one event, distance from that building matters more than distance from downtown.
What the hotels in New Buffalo are like
Before the list, the shape of it. These figures cover every property the search found within about five miles of the middle of New Buffalo — not just the 36 shown below, which are simply the closest.
| Measure | New Buffalo | What it tells you |
|---|---|---|
| Properties found | 63 | Everything listed within about five miles of the centre. The 36 nearest are shown below. |
| Star mix | 2 × 5★, 26 × 4★, 17 × 3★, 5 × 2★ | 4-star is the largest band here. |
| Average guest score | 8.2/10 | Across the 37 rated properties. Supplied by our accommodation partner, not a StubOrder rating. |
| Within a mile of the centre | 4 of 63 | The rest are a drive or a transit ride. |
| Closest property | 0.7 mi | From the city’s centre point, in a straight line. |
Hotels in New Buffalo, closest to the centre first
Pick your dates to price these for the nights you actually want. Nothing is quoted until you do, because a nightly rate for the wrong dates is worse than no rate at all.
-
Fairfield Inn & Suites by Marriott New Buffalo
11400 Holiday Drive, New Buffalo
Indoor Pool and Fitness Center Enjoy a dip in the indoor pool or break a sweat in the fitness center during your stay at Fairfield Inn & Suites. Complimentary Amenities Stay conne…
-
Holiday Inn Express & Suites New Buffalo, MI by IHG
11500 Holiday Dr, New Buffalo
Convenient Location and Amenities Located in New Buffalo, MI, the 2-star Holiday Inn Express & Suites offers free WiFi, an indoor pool, and a daily complimentary continental break…
-
Quality Inn Near Interstate I94
18830 Laporte Rd, New Buffalo
Luxurious Amenities and Features The Quality Inn Near Interstate I94 offers a range of top-notch amenities, including a complimentary breakfast, high-speed internet, and an indoor…
-
Baymont by Wyndham New Buffalo
18800 Harbor Country Drive, New Buffalo
Luxurious Amenities Experience ultimate relaxation with our heated indoor pool and spa bath in select rooms. Enjoy a delicious hot breakfast to start your day right. Convenient Fa…
-
Four Winds Casino Resort – New Buffalo
11111 Wilson Road, New Buffalo
Luxurious Amenities Indulge in the 2 spa tubs or test your luck at the casino. Enjoy complimentary WiFi and concierge services, along with a convenient area shuttle. Dining and En…
-
Deer Haus by Juniper Holiday + Home
16 Walden Way, New Buffalo
Luxurious Amenities Deer Haus offers a tranquil garden and an inviting outdoor fireplace for guests to enjoy. Free WiFi and private parking add convenience to your stay. Comfortab…
-
Schoolhouse Rock by Juniper Holiday + Home
7 Pond Path, New Buffalo
Charming Garden Setting Luxurious Amenities Convenient Location Near New Buffalo Beach Book your stay at Schoolhouse Rock for an unforgettable vacation experience!
-
Wild Horse Run by Juniper Holiday + Home
115 Franklin St., New Buffalo
Luxurious Accommodation Enjoy a spacious holiday home with 4 bedrooms and modern amenities, including a fully equipped kitchen and cozy fireplace. Outdoor Entertainment Relax in t…
-
The Moose House by Juniper Holiday + Home
101 S. Griffith Street, New Buffalo
Luxurious Amenities Indulge in the comfort of air conditioning, a fully equipped kitchen, and an outdoor fireplace. Family-Friendly Features Enjoy a children's playground and spac…
-
Lodged in the Trees
1005 Bell Avenue, New Buffalo
Scenic Mountain Views Experience stunning mountain views while staying at Lodged in the Trees. With a serene garden and outdoor dining area, immerse yourself in the natural beauty…
-
Square Toe's Last Resort
519 West Michigan Street, New Buffalo
Charming Patio and Garden Experience comfort and relaxation in our air-conditioned holiday home with a lovely patio and garden, providing a serene setting for your vacation in New…
-
New Buffalo Inn
231 E Buffalo Street, New Buffalo
Luxurious Spa Facilities Indulge in relaxation with our on-site massage services and a rejuvenating hot tub. Convenient Amenities Enjoy air-conditioned rooms with free WiFi, equip…
-
Walking Distance To Beach And Shops
619 East Buffalo Street, New Buffalo
Close to Beach and Shops Family-Friendly Amenities Enjoy a worry-free stay with our kids' club, indoor play area, and children's playground. We also provide a baby safety gate for…
-
The Neighborhood Hotel - New Buffalo
18 W Merchant St, New Buffalo
Luxurious Accommodation with a Touch of Nature Garden Oasis: Enjoy the serene garden setting at The Neighborhood Hotel New Buffalo, perfect for relaxing after a day at the nearby …
-
Blocks to Town, Game Room, Firepit, Huge Backyard
18393 Ridge Road, New Buffalo
Fantastic Location: Enjoy the convenience of being just blocks away from town and only 2.2 km from the picturesque New Buffalo Beach. Fun for Everyone: Indulge in quality family t…
-
Charming New Buffalo Condo: Walk to Lake Michigan!
235 N Whittaker St, New Buffalo
Recreation and Amenities Enjoy the outdoor pool or make use of complimentary Wi-Fi. Free self parking is available. Cozy Apartment Relax in this air-conditioned apartment with a f…
-
Idyllic New Buffalo Condo: Walk to Beach & Shops!
235 N Whittaker St, New Buffalo
Outdoor Pool and Complimentary Wi-Fi Enjoy the outdoor pool and stay connected with complimentary wireless internet access during your stay. Entertainment and Convenience Unwind i…
-
Eagles Beach Nest II
115 North Eagle Street, New Buffalo
Spectacular Lake Views Explore the beauty of Lake Michigan right from your accommodation at Eagles Beach Nest II. Modern Amenities Enjoy the convenience of free WiFi, a fully equi…
-
Lake Michigan Getaway by Juniper Holiday + Home
1414 Shore Dr., New Buffalo
Lake Views and Outdoor Fireplace Enjoy stunning views of Lake Michigan from the comfort of your accommodation. Cozy up by the outdoor fireplace while taking in the serene surround…
-
Upscale Family Retreat w/ Fire Pit, Walk to Beach!
16440 Lakeshore Road, Union Pier
Amenities: Complimentary wireless internet access Arcade/game room Free self parking Features: Air-conditioned cottage with a fireplace Private patio Fully equipped kitchen Nearby…
-
Beachglass Cottage - Family Friendly Kids and Pets
46355 Grand Beach Road, Grand Beach
Charming Beachfront Escape Seaside Serenity: Nestled in Grand Beach, Michigan, Beachglass Cottage offers a tranquil retreat with free WiFi, private parking, and a lush garden for …
-
Goldberry Woods
9902 Community Hall Rd, Union Pier
Recreational Opportunities: Take advantage of the outdoor pool and spa tub at Goldberry Woods for a relaxing stay. Complimentary Services: Enjoy amenities like free Wi-Fi, concier…
-
Casa Azur by Juniper Holiday + Home
16325 1st St, Union Pier
Luxurious Accommodation with Private Pool Indulge in a lavish stay at Casa Azur, a holiday home offering a private pool and free WiFi. Unwind in the garden or cozy up by the outdo…
-
The Neighborhood Hotel Grand Beach
19400 Ravine Dr, New Buffalo
Luxurious Accommodation Experience 5-star luxury at The Neighborhood Hotel Grand Beach in New Buffalo. Enjoy air-conditioned rooms with free WiFi and private bathrooms. Some rooms…
-
The High Life by Juniper Holiday + Home
14480 Woodcrest Ln, New Buffalo
Luxurious Amenities Indulge in a spacious 3-bedroom holiday home with a fully equipped kitchen, outdoor fireplace, and garden. Scenic Surroundings Enjoy the ambience from the outd…
-
Lake Michigan Hideaway: Pool, Steps to Beach!
95 E Court Dr, New Buffalo
Outdoor Pool and Complimentary Amenities Enjoy the outdoor pool and complimentary amenities at our cozy cottage, perfect for a relaxing getaway. Fully Equipped Kitchen and Private…
-
Charming Union Pier Home w/ Deck: Half-mi to Beach
9963 Town Line Ave, Union Pier
Convenient Amenities Enjoy complimentary wireless internet access and barbecue grills. Free self parking is available on-site. Well-Equipped Cottage Relax in this air-conditioned …
-
Hot Tub, Deck & Backyard: Cozy Union Pier House!
16074 Greenwood Avenue, Union Pier
Convenient Amenities Make use of complimentary wireless internet access, an arcade/game room, and barbecue grills. Free self-parking is available on-site. Cozy Cottage Features Re…
-
Garden Grove Inn Bed and Breakfast
9549 Union Pier Road, Union Pier
Tranquil Retreat Amongst Nature Unique Rooms with Modern Comforts: Each room at our Union Pier bed and breakfast is thoughtfully designed with antique furnishings, a cozy sitting …
-
Luxury Family Home w/ Deck, Swim Spa & Grill!
4049 Creek Dr, New Buffalo
Outdoor Pool and Recreation Options: Take advantage of the outdoor pool and various recreation opportunities available at the property. Complimentary Amenities: Enjoy complimentar…
-
Renovated, Spacious Retreat in Union Pier!
15920 Prusa Rd, Union Pier
Convenient Amenities Enjoy complimentary wireless internet and an arcade/game room. Free self-parking is provided for your convenience. Cozy Accommodations Relax in this air-condi…
-
8 Mi to Lake Michigan: Creative Retreat w/ Deck!
Experience the perfect getaway at our smoke-free apartment, ideally situated for both relaxation and adventure. Cozy Accommodations Step inside to find a comfortable living space …
-
The Inn at Union Pier
9708 Berrien Street, Union Pier
Unique Furnishings and Amenities Located just steps away from Lake Michigan, The Inn at Union Pier offers guests a one-of-a-kind experience with uniquely furnished rooms featuring…
-
Fire Fly Resort
15657 Lakeshore Road, Union Pier
Tranquil Garden Views Appreciate the peaceful garden views while enjoying complimentary wireless internet and a convenient picnic area. Benefit from free onsite parking during you…
-
The Dakota by Juniper Holiday + Home
15793 Locke Road, Union Pier
Luxurious Amenities The Dakota offers a private pool, a garden, and an outdoor fireplace, providing the perfect setting for relaxation and entertainment. Modern Comforts With 4 be…
-
Nan's Escape by Juniper Holiday + Home
15616 Nannene Ave., Union Pier
Luxurious Amenities Nan's Escape boasts a garden and outdoor fireplace for guests to enjoy. The spacious holiday home includes three bedrooms, a fully equipped kitchen, and two ba…
Staying near a specific New Buffalo venue
This is usually the better question. The hotels above are measured from the middle of New Buffalo, which is only the right anchor if the city itself is the trip. If you are coming for one event, what matters is how far you are from that building at 11pm — and in most cities the centre and the venue are not the same place.
Each page below runs its own search from that venue’s own coordinates and sorts by real straight-line distance from the doors, with a plain note on every card saying whether that is a walk, a long walk or a drive.
Venues in New Buffalo
The buildings people book these rooms for. Each links to its schedule and tickets.
What is on in New Buffalo
The reason most people book a room here. Every date links to live tickets and a seat map.
- From about $155.00View Tickets
- From about $138.00View Tickets
- From about $109.00View Tickets
- From about $108.00View Tickets
- From about $88.00View Tickets
- From about $60.00View Tickets
Halloween
Wheel Of Fortune Live!
From about $53.00View Tickets- From about $53.00View Tickets
How to read these listings
Every card carries the same facts in the same order, so two properties can be compared at a glance rather than read as marketing copy.
- Distance is straight-line, not walking. We know where the property is and where the centre is; we do not know the streets in between. That is why each card also says walkable, long walk or drive, and why those labels are deliberately conservative.
- Guest scores are our accommodation partner’s, not ours. StubOrder does not review hotels. Where a score appears it is theirs, with the review count beside it so you can judge how much weight it carries.
- The rate is the lowest available for the stay you asked for, for two adults, and it moves constantly. Treat it as a comparison between properties rather than a quote.
- Nothing here is paid placement. The order is distance from the centre, full stop. No property pays to appear or to rank.
Plan the rest of the trip
Frequently asked questions
What kind of hotels are there in New Buffalo?
The stock is mixed, with 4-star the largest single band at 26 of 63, and 4 of them are within a mile of the centre. They average 8.2/10 in guest scores from our accommodation partner.
How close are these hotels to the New Buffalo venues?
The hotels on this page are measured from the middle of New Buffalo. For distance from a specific building, use that venue's own page - each one is linked above and sorts every nearby property by real distance from the doors.
Why are no prices shown until I pick dates?
Because a nightly rate only means anything for a specific stay, and asking for one costs a live request. Pick your dates and every property above is priced for exactly those nights, for two adults.
Does StubOrder sell hotels and tickets together?
No. Tickets come from our resale marketplace and rooms from our accommodation partner, as two separate bookings with separate confirmations.
Is it cheaper to stay near the venue or in the centre?
It depends on the city and the night. Near a stadium on an event night is usually the expensive option; the centre is usually better value but adds a journey. Both pages exist so you can compare them rather than guess.
