Hotels
Hotels in Montauk, NY
The stock is mixed, with 3-star the largest single band at 42 of 87, and 39 of them are within a mile of The Surf Lodge. The hotel search for Montauk starts at The Surf Lodge, so every distance below is measured from there, nearest first.
Hotels in Montauk: our accommodation partner lists 87 properties within about five miles of The Surf Lodge, 39 of them within a mile. They average 8.0/10 in guest scores. The 36 nearest are compared below, closest first.
What the hotels in Montauk are like
Before the list, the shape of it. These figures cover every property the search found within about five miles of The Surf Lodge, not just the 36 shown below, which are simply the closest.
| Measure | Montauk | What it tells you |
|---|---|---|
| Properties found | 87 | Everything listed within about five miles of The Surf Lodge. The 36 nearest are shown below. |
| Star mix | 5 × 5★, 15 × 4★, 42 × 3★, 18 × 2★ | 3-star is the largest band here. |
| Average guest score | 8.0/10 | Across the 66 rated properties. Supplied by our accommodation partner, not a StubOrder rating. |
| Within a mile of The Surf Lodge | 39 of 87 | The rest are a drive or a transit ride. |
| Closest property | Under 0.3 mi | From The Surf Lodge, in a straight line. |
Hotels in Montauk, closest to The Surf Lodge first
Pick your dates to price these for the nights you actually want. Nothing is quoted until you do, because a nightly rate for the wrong dates is worse than no rate at all.
-
The Surf Lodge
183 Edgemere St, Montauk
Discover the perfect blend of luxury and nature at The Surf Lodge in Montauk, where breathtaking views meet impeccable service. Comfortable Accommodations Unwind in one of our 20 …
-
Montauk Manor
236 Edgemere St., Montauk
Luxurious Spa Services Montauk Manor, nestled in Montauk, New York, offers exquisite on-site spa services for the ultimate relaxation experience. Indulge in rejuvenating treatment…
-
Sole East Resort
90 Second House Rd, Montauk
Luxurious Accommodation Indulge in modern designed guest rooms with Smart TVs and bungalow-style rooms featuring natural black slate flooring. Enjoy the bright, open spaces and up…
-
Ruschmeyers
161 Second House Rd, Montauk
Convenient Amenities Make use of convenient amenities such as complimentary wireless internet access, concierge services, and a picnic area. Dining Experience Enjoy a satisfying m…
-
Ruschmeyers #3 - Queen
161 Second House Rd., Montauk
Nearby Attractions Explore the vibrant nightlife and dining options at Fort Pond. Spend a relaxing day at The Hamptons Beaches, just a short walk away. Visit the historical Second…
-
Ruschmeyers #17 - Dlx King
161 Second House Rd., Montauk
Convenient Location Located just a short walk from Fort Pond and The Hamptons Beaches, this vacation home offers easy access to popular attractions. Nearby Beaches Explore the bea…
-
Ruschmeyers #19 - Dlx King
161 Second House Rd., Montauk
Prime Location Enjoy the convenience of being steps away from Fort Pond and a short walk to The Hamptons Beaches. Explore nearby attractions like Second House Museum and Kirk Park…
-
Ruschmeyers #5 - Queen
161 Second House Rd., Montauk
Nearby Attractions Explore the area with ease - Fort Pond, The Hamptons Beaches, and Second House Museum nearby. Beach Proximity Conveniently located just a short walk away from F…
-
Ruschmeyers #11 - Dlx Queen
161 Second House Rd., Montauk
Prime Location Near Attractions Situated just steps away from Fort Pond and minutes from The Hamptons Beaches, Ruschmeyers #11 - Dlx Queen is an ideal choice for those looking to …
-
Ruschmeyers #4 - Queen
161 Second House Rd., Montauk
Prime Location for Beach Lovers Explore Fort Pond, The Hamptons Beaches, and more within minutes of our hotel. Cozy Accommodations Enjoy a comfortable stay in our Queen room at Ru…
-
Ruschmeyers #6 - Queen
161 Second House Rd., Montauk
Nearby Attractions and Beaches: Explore popular spots like Fort Pond, The Hamptons Beaches, and more within walking distance. Convenient Airport Access: Travel hassle-free with se…
-
Ruschmeyers #12 - Dlx Queen
161 Second House Rd., Montauk
Prime Location Unwind just steps away from Fort Pond and The Hamptons Beaches at this Montauk aparthotel. Nearby Attractions Explore top beaches like Fort Pond Bay Beach and enjoy…
-
The Montauk Beach House
55 S Elmwood Ave., Montauk
Luxurious Amenities The Montauk Beach House offers an outdoor swimming pool, gift shop, café, and snack bar. Guests can enjoy cocktails by the poolside and shop for clothing and b…
-
Duryea's Sunset Cottages
Experience the ultimate escape at Duryea's Sunset Cottages, where tranquility meets breathtaking views. Private Beach Bliss Unwind on our exclusive private beach, the perfect sanc…
-
Daunt's Albatross Motel
44 South Elmwood Ave, Montauk
Recreational Amenities Enjoy the outdoor pool and bicycles for rent at Daunt's Albatross Motel. Additionally, make use of complimentary wireless internet, a picnic area, and barbe…
-
Aqualina Inn Montauk
20 South Elmwood Avenue, Montauk
Recreational Amenities Enjoy a seasonal outdoor pool and take in the view from the garden. Additional Features Complimentary wireless internet, concierge services, and a picnic ar…
-
Daunts Albatross Motel
44 S Elmwood Ave, Montauk
Outdoor Swimming Pool and BBQ Facilities Enjoy a refreshing dip in the outdoor swimming pool or gather with friends and family for a fun BBQ at Daunts Albatross Motel. The perfect…
-
A Wave Inn - Montauk
32 Elmwood Avenue , Montauk
Beachside Bliss Relaxing Amenities: Enjoy the outdoor pool and barbecue facilities for a leisurely stay. Comfortable Accommodations: Each room features cable TV, microwave, and re…
-
Sole East Beach
107 S Emerson Ave, Montauk
Convenient Amenities Enjoy complimentary wireless internet access and on-site vending machine during your stay. Comfortable Accommodations Relax in one of the 26 air-conditioned r…
-
Montauk Oceanside Suites
115 South Emerson Avenue, Montauk
Convenient Amenities Enjoy complimentary wireless internet access, a picnic area, and barbecue grills. The front desk is available during limited hours for your convenience, and f…
-
Apartment in Royal Atlantic Beach Resort - Montauk
126 S Emerson Ave, Montauk
Luxurious Beach Resort Experience Seaside Serenity: Nestled just 500 meters from Kirk Park Beach, the Apartment in Royal Atlantic Beach Resort in Montauk offers a tranquil retreat…
-
The Surf Club
20 Surfside Avenue, Montauk
Luxurious Amenities: Enjoy the outdoor pool, sauna, and fitness center, along with complimentary Wi-Fi, concierge services, and room service. Convenient Features: Benefit from lug…
-
Ocean Resort Inn
95 S Emerson Ave, Montauk
Recreational Amenities and Views Enjoy the seasonal outdoor pool and garden views at Ocean Resort Inn. Convenience and Services Experience complimentary Wi-Fi, concierge services,…
-
Offshore Montauk
Experience the ultimate retreat at Offshore Montauk, your beachfront haven in the heart of Montauk. Recreation and Relaxation Dive into our refreshing outdoor pool or soak up the …
-
Montauk Blue Hotel
108 S Emerson Ave, Montauk
Stunning Ocean Views and Indoor Pool Experience the beauty of Montauk at our resort, just steps away from Main Town Beach. Enjoy breathtaking ocean views from our large sun deck a…
-
Ocean Surf Resort
84 South Emerson Avenue, Montauk
Beachfront Paradise Prime Location: Nestled in Montauk, Ocean Surf Resort is just steps away from Kirk Park Beach and Hither Hills State Park, offering guests a perfect beach geta…
-
Hero Beach Club
626 Montauk Hwy, Montauk
Beachfront Property with Stunning Views Outdoor Pool and Relaxing Services Enjoy a refreshing dip in the outdoor swimming pool or indulge in in-room massage services arranged by o…
-
Marram
21 Oceanview Terrace, Montauk
Beachfront Property with Ocean Views Luxurious Amenities Enjoy a stay in our light rooms with soothing decor, a dining area, and a small refrigerator. Our Marram rooms and studios…
-
Beach Plum Resort
779 Old Montauk Highway, Montauk
Outdoor Pool and Terrace Embrace the sun by relaxing at the outdoor pool or soaking in the breathtaking views from the terrace. Complimentary Amenities Enjoy free wireless interne…
-
Breakers Montauk
769 Old Montauk Highway, Montauk
Full-Service Spa for Relaxation Indulge in rejuvenating massages at our on-site spa, perfect for unwinding after a day of exploration. Dining Options to Satisfy Your Cravings Savo…
-
Glendale by Rove 5BR w Outdoor Space Heated Pool
25 Glendale Drive Montauk New York, Montauk
Scenic Garden Views Complimentary Amenities Enjoy free self-parking, complimentary wireless internet access, and barbecue grills during your stay. Convenient Location Located with…
-
Beachcomber Resort at Montauk
727 Old Montauk Highway, Montauk
Discover your coastal retreat at Beachcomber Resort at Montauk, where relaxation meets adventure! Beachside Bliss Just a minute's stroll from The Hamptons Beaches, our prime locat…
-
Atlantic Bluffs Club
707 Old Montauk Hwy, Montauk
Luxurious Accommodations with Full Kitchens Feel at home in our air-conditioned rooms with fully equipped kitchens, perfect for longer stays. Enjoy the convenience of full-sized r…
-
Hartman's Briney Breezes Beach Resort
693 Old Montauk Highway, Montauk
Beachfront Location: Located opposite the beach in Montauk, Hartman’s Briney Breezes Motel offers a picturesque setting for a relaxing getaway. Enjoy stunning sea views right from…
-
15 Ditch
15 Ditch Plains Raod, Montauk
Beach Proximity Enjoy a beach getaway at 15 Ditch in Montauk, just a stone's throw away from The Hamptons Beaches and Ditch Plains Beach. Complimentary Amenities Experience the co…
-
Harborside Motel
371 W Lake Dr, Montauk
Recreation Opportunities Enjoy the outdoor tennis court and seasonal pool for leisure activities. Featured Amenities Take advantage of complimentary Wi-Fi, picnic area, and barbec…
Want a wider list than the one above? You can also search Expedia's own hotel inventory. We do not show its prices here.
How we earn: StubOrder may earn a commission when you book through the Expedia links on this page. It costs you nothing extra, and it never changes which events, venues or places we show you.
Compare more hotels on Expedia (opens Expedia in a new tab)Staying near a specific Montauk venue
In Montauk the hotels above are already measured from The Surf Lodge, so its own hotels page below lists much the same properties, with what is on there.
Venues in Montauk
The buildings people book these rooms for. Each links to its schedule and tickets.
How to read these listings
Every card carries the same facts in the same order, so two properties can be compared at a glance rather than read as marketing copy.
- Distance is straight-line, not walking. We know where the property is and where The Surf Lodge is; we do not know the streets in between. That is why each card also says walkable, long walk or drive, and why those labels are deliberately conservative.
- Guest scores are our accommodation partner’s, not ours. StubOrder does not review hotels. Where a score appears it is theirs, with the review count beside it so you can judge how much weight it carries.
- The rate is the lowest available for the stay you asked for, for two adults, and it moves constantly. Treat it as a comparison between properties rather than a quote.
- Nothing here is paid placement. The order is distance from The Surf Lodge, full stop. No property pays to appear or to rank.
Plan the rest of the trip
Email me when a new date is announced, so I can book a room early
Frequently asked questions
How close are these hotels to the Montauk venues?
The hotel search for Montauk starts at The Surf Lodge, so every distance on this page is measured from there, in a straight line, and each card says plainly whether that is a walk or a drive.
Does StubOrder sell hotels and tickets together?
No. Tickets come from our resale marketplace and rooms from our accommodation partner, as two separate bookings with separate confirmations.
What kind of hotels are there in Montauk?
The stock is mixed, with 3-star the largest single band at 42 of 87, and 39 of them are within a mile of The Surf Lodge. They average 8.0/10 in guest scores from our accommodation partner.
Why are no prices shown until I pick dates?
Because a nightly rate only means anything for a specific stay, and asking for one costs a live request. Pick your dates and every property above is priced for exactly those nights, for two adults.
