Hotels in Bay Shore
The stock is mixed, with 3-star the largest single band at 10 of 18, and 3 of them are within a mile of the centre. Below are the closest properties to the middle of Bay Shore, nearest first, plus what is near each venue in the city — because if you are here for one event, distance from that building matters more than distance from downtown.
What the hotels in Bay Shore are like
Before the list, the shape of it. These figures cover every property the search found within about five miles of the middle of Bay Shore — not just the 18 shown below, which are simply the closest.
| Measure | Bay Shore | What it tells you |
|---|---|---|
| Properties found | 18 | Everything listed within about five miles of the centre. The 18 nearest are shown below. |
| Star mix | 1 × 4★, 10 × 3★, 4 × 2★, 1 × 1★ | 3-star is the largest band here. |
| Average guest score | 7.1/10 | Across the 15 rated properties. Supplied by our accommodation partner, not a StubOrder rating. |
| Within a mile of the centre | 3 of 18 | The rest are a drive or a transit ride. |
| Closest property | 0.4 mi | From the city’s centre point, in a straight line. |
Hotels in Bay Shore, closest to the centre first
Pick your dates to price these for the nights you actually want. Nothing is quoted until you do, because a nightly rate for the wrong dates is worse than no rate at all.
-
The Ocean Bay House
69 Ocean Ave, Bay Shore
Luxurious Adults-Only Retreat Serenity and Comfort: Immerse yourself in the tranquility of river and quiet street views at The Ocean Bay House. Each unit boasts a terrace, flat-sc…
-
LUXURY BAY SHORE HOME
Discover your perfect getaway at our charming vacation home in Bay Shore, where relaxation meets convenience. Prime Location Nestled just a stone's throw away from the scenic Gilg…
-
Travelodge by Wyndham Bay Shore Long Island
501 E Main Street, Bay Shore
Discover a charming oasis at Travelodge by Wyndham Bay Shore Long Island, perfectly situated just moments from fantastic local attractions. Location Perks Our hotel is convenientl…
-
The President Mansion Luxurious 7br Family Retreat 7 Bedroom Home by RedAwning
717 South Country Road, Bay Shore
Scenic Views and Fun Games Enjoy the garden views while making use of the arcade/game room and barbecue grills. Relaxation and Entertainment Unwind in the private spa tub and enjo…
-
Bay Shore Inn
300 Bay Shore Rd, Bay Shore
Welcome to Bayshore Inn! Convenient Amenities: Enjoy free Wi-Fi and cable TV with HBO in our cozy rooms. Some rooms even feature a relaxing spa bath, perfect for unwinding after a…
-
Cozy Nesting
47 Massachusetts Avenue, Bay Shore
Convenient Location Modern Amenities Complimentary Services Book now to experience the perfect blend of comfort and convenience at Cozy Nesting.
-
Cozy Bay Shore Condo Near Museums & Outdoor Rec!
15A Hemlock Dr, Bay Shore
Modern Amenities This smoke-free apartment offers a comfortable stay with complimentary parking nearby. Enjoy the convenience of an air-conditioned space with a fully equipped kit…
-
Bay Shore Vacation Rental ~ 7 Mi to the Beach
95 Hyde Park Ave, Bay Shore
Marina and Hunting On-Site Enjoy the convenience of having an onsite marina and the option for hunting right at the property. Free Self Parking Take advantage of the complimentary…
-
Bay Shore Vacation Rental w/ Shared Yard!
95 Hyde Park Ave, Bay Shore
Convenient Location Situated in Bay Shore, this apartment offers easy access to nearby attractions such as Brentwood State Park and Sky Zone, perfect for guests looking for entert…
-
North Babylon Home, Near Belmont Lake State Park!
13 Mohawk Dr, North Babylon
Convenient Location Situated in North Babylon, this cottage is just a short drive away from popular attractions like Monster Mini Golf and Tanger Outlets. Family-Friendly Amenitie…
-
Residence Inn by Marriott Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex
7 Courthouse Drive, Central Islip
Indulge in Comfort and Convenience Luxurious Amenities: Enjoy a stay at Residence Inn by Marriott Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex, featuring a full kitchen, flat-screen TV, i…
-
Courtyard by Marriott Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex
11 Courthouse Dr., Central Islip
Modern Accommodation Experience comfort and convenience at Courtyard by Marriott Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex. Our modern hotel offers free WiFi and complimentary parking …
-
Relax Inn North Babylon
915 Sunrise Highway, North Babylon
Welcome to The Relax Inn, a charming motel nestled in the heart of West Babylon. Convenient Location: Enjoy easy access to local restaurants, lounges, parks, golf clubs, museums, …
-
Deer Park Motor Inn
354 Commack Rd, Deer Park
Convenient Location Near Attractions Stay at Deer Park Motor Inn and be within minutes of Monster Mini Golf and Tanger Outlets. The motel's proximity to popular attractions makes …
-
Bedroom
124 Gibson Avenue, Brentwood
Prime Location in Brentwood Convenient Amenities Nearby Attractions To book your stay at our non-smoking property in Brentwood, conveniently located near top attractions and with …
-
New York Abode w/ Pool & Patio, Near Times Square!
16 Rock Rd, Islip Terrace
Make use of convenient amenities, which include complimentary wireless internet access and barbecue grills.Make yourself comfortable in this air-conditioned apartment, which featu…
-
Shop, Hike, Golf & Swim: Inviting Deer Park Escape
Discover a serene getaway just a short drive from some of Long Island's most popular attractions. Spacious Living: This air-conditioned apartment boasts 4 separate bedrooms, offer…
-
Dreamstay guest house
485 Irving Street, Central Islip
Convenient Location: Located in Central Islip, enjoy easy access to local attractions and amenities. Comfortable Accommodation: Our air-conditioned apartment includes a fully equi…
Staying near a specific Bay Shore venue
This is usually the better question. The hotels above are measured from the middle of Bay Shore, which is only the right anchor if the city itself is the trip. If you are coming for one event, what matters is how far you are from that building at 11pm — and in most cities the centre and the venue are not the same place.
Each page below runs its own search from that venue’s own coordinates and sorts by real straight-line distance from the doors, with a plain note on every card saying whether that is a walk, a long walk or a drive.
Venues in Bay Shore
The buildings people book these rooms for. Each links to its schedule and tickets.
- The Boulton Center For The Performing Arts
- Westfield South Shore
- Great South Bay Brewery
- Bayfront Home
- St Peter's By The Sea Episcopal Church
- Movie Lot Drive-In
- South Shore Mall
- Napper Tandy's Irish Pub - Bay Shore
What is on in Bay Shore
The reason most people book a room here. Every date links to live tickets and a seat map.
- From about $73.00View Tickets
- From about $24.00View Tickets
- From about $63.00View Tickets
- From about $103.00View Tickets
- From about $98.00View Tickets
- From about $69.00View Tickets
- From about $98.00View Tickets
- From about $66.00View Tickets
How to read these listings
Every card carries the same facts in the same order, so two properties can be compared at a glance rather than read as marketing copy.
- Distance is straight-line, not walking. We know where the property is and where the centre is; we do not know the streets in between. That is why each card also says walkable, long walk or drive, and why those labels are deliberately conservative.
- Guest scores are our accommodation partner’s, not ours. StubOrder does not review hotels. Where a score appears it is theirs, with the review count beside it so you can judge how much weight it carries.
- The rate is the lowest available for the stay you asked for, for two adults, and it moves constantly. Treat it as a comparison between properties rather than a quote.
- Nothing here is paid placement. The order is distance from the centre, full stop. No property pays to appear or to rank.
Plan the rest of the trip
Frequently asked questions
What kind of hotels are there in Bay Shore?
The stock is mixed, with 3-star the largest single band at 10 of 18, and 3 of them are within a mile of the centre. They average 7.1/10 in guest scores from our accommodation partner.
Is it cheaper to stay near the venue or in the centre?
It depends on the city and the night. Near a stadium on an event night is usually the expensive option; the centre is usually better value but adds a journey. Both pages exist so you can compare them rather than guess.
Does StubOrder sell hotels and tickets together?
No. Tickets come from our resale marketplace and rooms from our accommodation partner, as two separate bookings with separate confirmations.
How close are these hotels to the Bay Shore venues?
The hotels on this page are measured from the middle of Bay Shore. For distance from a specific building, use that venue's own page - each one is linked above and sorts every nearby property by real distance from the doors.
Why are no prices shown until I pick dates?
Because a nightly rate only means anything for a specific stay, and asking for one costs a live request. Pick your dates and every property above is priced for exactly those nights, for two adults.
